MotorTrend put the 2024 BMW X2 M35i through a full instrumented road test, recording a rapid 0–60 mph time of roughly 4.0 seconds, which ranks it among the quickest vehicles in its class. The review praises the chassis's excellent balance, sharp steering, and tenacious xDrive all-wheel-drive system, which together deliver a playful and involving driving experience that rivals some sporty hot hatches. The interior is praised for its solid build quality, supportive sport seats, and modern twin-screen setup, though the review notes some lower cabin plastics feel less premium than the price point suggests. The firm ride, especially with 20-inch wheels and adaptive dampers set to their hardest mode, is the main negative. MotorTrend also points out that the fastback roofline compromises rear-seat headroom and that the bold exterior styling drew mixed opinions among the staff. Overall, MotorTrend concludes that the X2 is one of the most driver-focused SUVs in the segment, a performance-oriented crossover that rewards enthusiasts willing to tolerate a stiffer ride for sharper dynamics. No star rating is given; the outlet relies on test data and a written verdict.

Car and Driver tested the redesigned 2024 BMW X2, praising the M35i's 312-hp turbocharged engine for brisk acceleration and a satisfying exhaust note. Handling is agile with well-weighted steering, making it one of the more engaging small crossovers. The interior impresses with quality materials and BMW's curved-display iDrive, but the ride is firm and the sloping roofline cuts into rear headroom and cargo space. It also costs significantly more than the related X1 without adding practicality. Car and Driver concluded it's a stylish, fun-to-drive choice for buyers who prioritize looks and driving enjoyment over utility.