Car and Driver has long praised the Audi SQ5 for its blend of daily usability and athletic performance. The current generation's turbocharged 3.0-liter V-6 produces 349 horsepower and 369 lb-ft of torque, enabling a zero-to-60-mph time of just 4.4 seconds in their testing. The SQ5's adaptive air suspension delivers a controlled yet compliant ride, and the steering is accurate if not overly communicative. The interior is a standout, with impeccable build quality, high-quality materials, and the latest MMI infotainment system that remains intuitive despite its complexity. While it faces stiff competition from the BMW X3 M40i and Mercedes-AMG GLC 43, the SQ5 distinguishes itself as the most refined and polished choice in the segment. Practicality remains intact with generous cargo space and comfortable rear seats. Car and Driver notes that the SQ5 is not the sharpest handler in its class, but its overall competence and versatility make it an easy recommendation for those seeking a sporty yet livable luxury SUV.

MotorTrend's comprehensive evaluation of the Audi SQ5 highlights its exceptional balance between performance and comfort. The turbocharged V-6 is smooth and responsive, with a satisfying surge of power across the rev range. The standard Quattro all-wheel-drive system provides superb traction in all weather conditions, and the eight-speed automatic transmission shifts quickly and seamlessly. MotorTrend particularly appreciates the SQ5's interior, which they describe as a benchmark in the compact luxury SUV segment. The available sport seats are both supportive and comfortable, and the digital cockpit is fully customizable and easy to read. In their instrumented testing, the SQ5 demonstrated strong braking performance and composed handling, though the ultimate limits are slightly lower than those of the BMW X3 M40i. However, MotorTrend concludes that the SQ5's refinement and everyday usability make it a more compelling overall package for most buyers.