MotorTrend's evaluation of the Alfa Romeo Tonale emphasizes its athletic road manners and distinctive Mediterranean flair. The review notes that the Tonale's chassis tuning delivers a firm but responsive ride, with responsive steering that makes it genuinely fun to drive on twisty roads. The interior features a modern design with available contrasting stitching and a large touchscreen, but some lower plastics feel cheap for the price. The plug-in hybrid Q4 version offers a useful electric-only range, but the base engine's real-world fuel economy disappoints. MotorTrend also points out that the rear seat space and trunk volume are tight compared to competitors. Despite these shortcomings, the SUV's character and driving pleasure give it a strong appeal for enthusiasts. The review scores the Tonale high for its handling and unique styling while acknowledging that it is a lifestyle choice rather than a family-hauling champion. Overall, MotorTrend gives it a 4 out of 5.

Edmunds' expert review of the Alfa Romeo Tonale focuses on its dual nature as both a handsome urban runabout and a decent performer. The testers appreciate the Tonale's quick acceleration from the turbo engine and the firm brake pedal, which aids confidence. The cabin is praised for its good visibility and supportive front seats, though the back seat is cramped for taller passengers. Edmunds notes that the infotainment system is straightforward once you learn the menu structure, but the voice control is subpar. Fuel economy ratings are average at best, especially for the base engine. The review also mentions that the Tonale's warranty is competitive, but the resale value is uncertain given Alfa Romeo's brand history. However, the undeniable style and fun-to-drive nature help offset these drawbacks. Edmunds concludes that while it's not the most practical or efficient choice, it's a compelling option for buyers who value emotional appeal in a small SUV. They give it a 4 out of 5 rating.